The statistics in which McNabblags, the ones that criticspoint to, are largelyarbitrary and irrelevant to quarterback greatnesscareer completion percentage, game-winning drives, fourth-quarter comebacks. No, not at all.". Plus, you can't be frail and be great. When talking about McNabbs impact on the NFL, context is more important than most other players. But McNabb quickly changed people's opinions about him, including owner Jeffrey Lurie, who signed him to a 12-year contract in 2002. The Eagles Should Make Jalen Hurts Their QB of the Future -- It's Time To Pay the Man. Patton was the games most dominant defensive back for a five-year stretch from 1958-62 after helping the Giants win an NFL championship in 1956. At 5-11, 228 pounds, he should be standing taller as a Hall of Famer. His numbers will, of course be higher than McNabbs career wise because of the difference in longevity. He was among a handful of QBs in the late 1990s and early 2000s to usher in an era of increased mobility from the position. Only three quarterbacks in NFL history have passed for more than 35,000 yards and also rushed for more than 3,000, and McNabb is one of them. Nick also has reporting experience with both the New York Jets, Giants, and New York Mets. He was all about finding a way to beat you, whether that meant taking on two linebackers with his head down to grind out a first down or buying time to improvise an impossible pass downfield to stretch a defense. 1. Aikman was great. Void in ONT. So we turn to Carmichael, a four-time Pro Bowler who set a high standard for big-framed (6-8, 225 pounds) wideouts. a yr & the half lets not act like he was throwing to great WRs most of his career he was throwing to trash cans at WR. 13 on the all-time rushing yards list, right behind Jim Brown and Marshall Faulk and just ahead of Marcus Allen and Franco Harris. WebSo McNabb is the only Hall-eligible QB whos played since 1975 whos made six or more Pro Bowls whos not in the Hall of Fame. Over the course of his 13-year career, He added two more strong years with the Jets. Not to mention he was one of the best dual-threat quarterbacks when he played and is currently 10th in all-time rushing yards by a quarterback. This is not the first time either player has been eligible for the Hall of Fame, but their inclusion here is notable nonetheless. Branch was one of the smoothest big-play receivers ever to play, and he deserves to be in Canton with his late quarterback, Ken Stabler. Included among the 122 modern-era nominees for the class of 2022? While the last couple decades havent been incredibly kind to Syracuse Orange football, that doesnt mean the programs history is lost on us or the Pro Football Hall of Fame, apparently. After nabbing both QB C.J. Does that mean his career is a failure? McNabb has been eligible for the Pro Football Hall of Fame since 2016, but has never been a finalist. Yet Aikman, who was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 2006, played for three Super Bowl champions. He completed 61 percent of his passes in that stretch for 25,760 yards and a solid, if unspectacular, 84.4 passer rating. Basically, I still think hewas right when he said that McNabb got the credit for the performance of the team, particularly Philadelphia's defense. 1999: 1 Tim Couch, 2 Donovan McNabb, 3 Akili Smith 2021: 1 Trevor Lawrence, 2 Zach Wilson, 3 Trey Lance 2023: 1 Bryce Young, 2 C.J. But Donovan got better after thatmuch better. Throughout his career, he was a top 10 QB in the game. There's no established criteria here, so you can use your own standards. Sign up for daily stories delivered to your inbox. I spent the weekend thinking quite a bit about Steve McNair, given the horrible events that took place in Nashville, Tenn., and talking to people who knew him well. The Pro Football Hall of Fame has announced its class of 2022. McNabb only threw over 30 touchdowns once in his whole career, but football was different 20 years ago. On behalf of Boot Hill Casino & resort (KS). He made only four Pro Bowls with only three 1,000-yard rushing seasons, but in just eight seasons with San Francisco, Craig also had 508 receptions, 11,506 yards from scrimmage and 66 total TDs. The fact McNabb went to five Conference Championship Games in his 10 years as a starter in Philadelphia makes him Hall-of-Fame worthy. I just continue to wait and see if it happens, it happens," McNabb said. Dan Marino never won the big game. Great communication . Donovan McNabb. McNabb originally did not receive a warm welcome to Philadelphia and was booed after he was drafted. His numbers speak for themselves -- yet still, all anyone looks at is the fact that he ended his career with zero Super Bowl rings. McNabb became eligible for the NFL Hall of Fame in 2017 and has been nominated each year since then. Unfortunately for McNabb, his postseason record is also one of the biggest knocks on his career and on his candidacy for the Hall of Fame. McNabb finished with 37,276 passing yards, 234 passing touchdowns and 117 career interceptions, while Aikman had 32,942 yards, 165 TDs and 141 INTs. How about Eli Manning? But heres to Holt, who had 869 catches for 12,660 yards in 10 seasons with the team. During his eight seasons with the Patriots, Seymour went to five Pro Bowls with three first-team All-Pro selections. Hall of famers Fran Tarkenton and Jim Kelly, for example, lost eight Super Bowls between the two of them. He may never have won a Super Bowl. James has been a finalist for three consecutive years, so the snub should end at some point soon, but its already considerable. Injuries limited Bosellis career to seven seasons in Jacksonville, but he was one of the games best edge blockers for most of it, with five Pro Bowl nods and three first-team All-Pro selections. The browser you are using is no longer supported on this site. All other NFL-related trademarks are trademarks of the National Football League. Delivery times may vary, especially during peak periods. Physically present in AZ/CO/CT/IL/IN/IA/KS/LA (select parishes)/MA/MD/MI/NH/NJ/NY/OH/OR/PA/TN/VA/WV/WY only. And as much as I like and respect Brunell, he isn't someone who likely will generate tremendous Hall of Fame debate. 5 retired by the Eagles in 2013. "Well, Peyton never won the big game until he won the Super Bowl. Barber also showed longevity and versatility. Donovan McNabb believes he's a Hall of Famer Around the League Presented By Donovan McNabb believes he's a Hall of Famer Published: Apr 18, 2012 He's not a guy who'll likely get in right away, but he deserves serious consideration, and we'd expect to eventually see him as a Hall of Fame finalist. Please also read our Privacy Notice and Terms of Use, which became effective December 20, 2019. Was he this? McNair also played a central role in some of the more memorable games in recent NFL history, including one of the best Super Bowls, and the "Music City Miracle" playoff victory over the Buffalo Bills. Unfortunately, both Barber and Bucs fans will have to wait at least another year. A ninth would tie the Orange with Miami and Pitt for No. Their career stats are almost identical (Brunell has played three more seasons, but he has seen little action since 2006): McNair: 60.1 completion percentage, 31,304 passing yards, 174 touchdown passes, 119 interceptions, 82.8 passer rating, 5.4 yards per carry, 37 rushing TDs. Refresh your browser window to try again. In the minds of some people, losing as many conference title games as he did, no matter how lacking the talent was around him, makes it impossible to get in the Hall. The Hall of A stronger argument still is that McNabb was a winner. Dan Fouts and Warren Moon both failed to reach the big game, and they both have a bust in Canton. This is hypocrisy. Multiple Super Bowl rings should not be a reason to put someone in the Hall of Fame, nor should it hold back a player who was unable to reach that plateau in the first place. If the losses truly matter, then lets compare him to another QB who lost championship games and yet is still in the HOF: Bills QB, Jim Kelly. And he may not have had the longevity and year-to-year dominance that separates the very good from the elite in the NFL. You can also keep future spots warm for Dwight Freeney and Chandler Jones as well, meaning theres a plausible future in the next 15 years where Syracuse has more Hall-of-Famers than all but two or three schools. The 2021 NFL Hall-of-Fame class will be inducted into Canton, Ohio in a little under a month. If you ask the NFL fans who dont really care about the game and only want to run with narratives, then McNabb is not a HOF QB. But the Hall should rethink that given how important special teams are and how much Tasker thrived in his role. He was just the third Black quarterback to start in the Super Bowl when he was under center for the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl XXXIX. Cornerback Lester Hayes is a close second, with five of his 10 Raiders seasons being exceptional. He took over a team that had gone 3-13 and had won 2 playoff games in 19 years. McNabb became eligible for the NFL Hall of Fame in 2017 and has been nominated each year since then. McNabb is arguably the top QB nominated (though Randall Cunningham and Steve McNair both inspire debate). Donovan McNabb is a Hall of Fame QB and Im tired of this narrative that he isnt. Despite a great playoff Former Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Donovan McNabb has been eligible for the Hall of Fame for a few years now, but during that time his name hasn't He never quite made it to that level, which is to say that I don't think there was a time when he was ever the best quarterback in the National Football League. McNabb told TMZ in 2019. James is No. In terms of stats relative to other Hall of Famers, his 47 career interceptions are only one less than Herb Adderley and Willie Wood, the same as Jimmy Johnson, and one more than Jack Christiansen and Mike Haynes. That cant be an accidental coincidence. From 2000-2004, Donovan McNabb was a top-five player in the National Football League. There are several great quarterbacks who never won a Super Bowl. The Eagles famously selected McNabb second overall instead of star running back Ricky Williams in 1999, much to the chagrin of fans in attendance that night in New York. The Panthers will soon claim Steve Smith and Julius Peppers as their first original Hall of Famers, but its fun to think about who otherwise stands out most from their 25 seasons of existence. Don't miss a story! McNabb had Brian Westbrook, and James Thrash as his two best receivers during that stretch. Hes also the only eligible QB to win nine playoff games whos not in the Hall of Fame. Adam Schein spotlights nine teams with exquisite prospect hauls. The team struggled, and McNabb had to get better. If he had had the Patriots' defense instead of the Eagles', Philly probably would have won. Ronde Barber is a legend in not only Tampa Bay football, but the game of football itself, and while the competition looks strong, its past the time the NFL enshrines him into the Hall of Fame. Donovan McNabb says he belongs in Hall of Fame: 'My numbers are better than Troy Aikman'. The talent around McNabb was also pretty poor. Call (800) 327-5050 or visit gamblinghelpline.ma.org (MA), Call 877-8-HOPENY/text HOPENY (467369) (NY). There isnot enough room in Canton to give everyone who qualifies as"very good"a call. The defense carried this team [the Eagles].". Anderson was in the league from 1982 to 2004, and the kicker is third on the career points list with 2,434. His team lost that game 24-21, but that was hardly a disgrace:McNabb had a pretty good Super Bowl, passing for 357 yards and three touchdowns. Steve McNair won an NFL MVP Award in 2003 with incredible talent on defense and at the skill positions. When passing wasnt so rampant and receiving numbers werent so gaudy in the 1970s and 80s, Carmichael was hard to cover in the red zone. He didnt win a Super Bowl, but neither did Warren Moon, Dan Fouts or Jim Kelly. Its time for McNabb to get his props and be in the Hall of Fame. Nov 29, 2009 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA Eagles QB DONOVAN MCNABB talks to the media after the game during the Washington Redskins and Philadelphia Eagles game in Philadelphia. Barbers resume has it all. McNabb lost four conference titles. "I didn't play the game to make the Hall of Fame. This years Hall of Fame celebration dinner will be held at 6 p.m. June 22 at the Bakersfield College Renegade Event Center at 1801 Panorama Drive. Lewis was named to the Pro Bowl and selected All-Pro in only one season, his 2,066-yard rushing explosion of 2003. While players do so many different things in each sport, the easiest way to compare and judge all of them is by success. Foster had 8,873 scrimmage yards and 68 total TDs in his seven seasons. Yet not all Super Bowl winning QBs have had, or will have their names called in Canton. The Eagles went 5-11 in McNabb's first year, and he only threw eight touchdowns in his first 12 NFL games. McNair twice had seasons of eight rushing touchdowns (1997, 1999), and he averaged 5.4 yards per carry in his career. Anderson was a seven-time Pro Bowler and, at his peak, was first-team All-Pro as NFL MVP and leader of the AFC champions in 1981. Two decades and a 13-year career later and McNabb possesses the title as WebAnswer (1 of 18): Donovan McNabb is definitely not a Hall of Fame QB. Kickers, punters and return men get limited love from the Hall of Fame, so its a long shot for a coverage ace. However, a Tampa Bay Buccaneers legend has been snubbed. The others: It was one of the best seasons ever for an NFL quarterback. The Redskins offensive line from the 1980s was great enough to have earned its unique nickname The Hogs but its crazy to think it has only one Hall of Fame presence in guard Russ Grimm. But it's not the be-all, end-all as a representation of an NFL player's greatness. He added another 31 while finishing his career with the Lions and Raiders. And from 2004 to the end of his career in 2011, he turned in a truly outstanding TD-to-interception ratio of 147-to-68. I can name three of us that should be following him, because at the end of the day, they're not understanding that the game is gonna open because behind us, it's gonna be about three-four more.". Things have eased up a lot with the coming of Washington D.C.'s Robert GriffinIII and Seattle's Russell Wilson. Most of these objections were summed up by Paul Domowitch of the Philadelphia Daily News. Howley was ahead of his time as a terrific athlete for the position, which gave him a modern-like edge in covering backs and receivers. Forgive me for cherry picking stats, but the list of quarterbacks that have accomplished what he's totaled is pretty impressive. "You can play the numbers game to make a case both for and against McNabb being Hall of Fame-worthy," Domowitch wrote, before opting to make the case against. File him under the Terrell Davis ethereal cases. I mean, there's nothing that I can do. My numbers are better than Troy Aikman," McNabb told TMZ Sports. The following browsers are supported: Chrome, Edge (v80 and later), Firefox and Safari. A player must have been retired at least five years before he can be considered for the Hall of Fame. Me, I would vote for both. "What happens a lot of times is we look at what the list says, so we talk about the five NFC Championship Games, the six Pro Bowls and then we come to the end, 'Well, he never won the big game,'" McNabb told Mark Kriegel of FoxSports.com, via the Philadelphia Daily News. "'I don't think there's a sports franchise in America that wouldn't like to be in our position to have a franchise quarterback that is as talented, as humble, as self-confident, as team-oriented,'' Lurie said. DONOVAN MCNABB 2007 BOWMAN CHROME REFRACTOR.. cleared payment - opens in a new window or tab, - for PayPal Credit, opens in a new window or tab, Report this item - opens in new window or tab. In his time, in his era, was he a top-five, top-10 quarterback in the league?". Regarding the larger issue of race, I don't think I can say it better than I did a decade ago: "Limbaugh is being excoriated for making race an issue in the NFL. Donovan McNabb has quickly fallen from an upper-tier NFL quarterback to a man without a job discussing his legacy. How about the fact that Manning led the league in interceptions three different times when McNabb never had a dubious distinction like that? He also stretched the field with a 15.2 yards-per-catch average. Donovan McNabb. He should be known for being an iron-man member of the Purple People Eaters, right there with Hall of Famers Alan Page and Carl Eller. As with every Hall of Fame player, context is key. At least, that's what Ryan Pace wants you to believe in the months between now and the start of the regular season. Seymour went to two more Pro Bowls in his 30s with the Raiders to close a mighty 12-year career. If both players get in, theyd tie with Ohio State for fourth. But many in the football press who disagree. McNabb, who has never been a finalist for the Hall, is convinced he's worthy. He won't be eligible for four years, but it doesn't hurt to start early. Quarterbacks Randall Cunningham and Donovan McNabb have interesting cases, but neither is strong enough. Odds and lines subject to change. Not only did Lynch make the Pro Bowl in five of 11 seasons in Tampa as ball-hawk and hard-hitter, but he also made four more with the Broncos in his 30s to close his career. Victor Cruz, Odell Beckham Jr. followed after. It's not too early to call Patrick Mahomes a fairly sure thing for the Hall of Fame seeing as he's already getting some G.O.A.T. Peyton The biggest thing holding McNabb back of being in Canton right now is the fact that he was 1-4 in conference title games and lost his only Super Bowl appearance. Barbers incredible resume not being enough in the eyes of the voters is one thing. He threw for 37,276 yards throughout his career, which is more than by current Hall of Famers Aikman, Terry Bradshaw and Jim Kelly. We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our site, show personalized content and targeted ads, analyze site traffic, and understand where our audiences come from. He won league MVP in 2005 while pounding out 1,880 yards and 27 TDs and carrying the Seahawks offense to Super Bowl 40. NFL footage NFL Productions LLC. His numbers (589 catches for 8,978 yards and 79 TDs) dont add up to the best of the current era, but back then, those numbers signaled an elite impact. consideration in just three years as a starter. McNabb won nine playoff games. Eli had Tiki Barber, Plaxico Burress, Amani Toomer, and Jeremy Shockey for the early parts of his career. Jacoby also was a playoff force, helping Washington win three Super Bowls. While that is the norm -- and many would argue is the right way to go about this -- it still leaves room for great players to slip through the cracks because their teams did not win it all. WebFind many great new & used options and get the best deals for DONOVAN MCNABB 2007 BOWMAN CHROME REFRACTOR..HALL OF FAMER.EAGLES at the best online Marshall is known for one of the biggest on-field blunders in NFL history, a wrong-way defensive TD run that turned into a 49ers safety during a Vikings regular-season victory in 1964. Sorry, you couldn't help itbut no.". Before drafting McNabb second overall, Philadelphia had only advanced past the divisional round once, in 1980. McNabb said he'd "absolutely" vote for himself to be in the Hall of Fame, which is a comment that will be mocked in Philadelphia. McNair got it done with his arms and his legs, and he helped bring stability and an identity to the Houston Oilers franchise as it relocated to Tennessee and became the Titans. Perhaps the greatest moment in franchise history wasRonde Barberspick-six of Donovan McNabb to shut down Veterans Stadium, slay the dragon that was the Philadelphia Eagles, and send the Bucs to their first Super Bowl, resulting in their first championship. PHILADELPHIA -- When Donovan McNabb arrived in Philadelphia in 1999, he became one of the three generational sports stars in town at the time. I found myself in the improbable position of defending Limbaugh at Slate. Its as if a Super Bowl ring is the only thing holding back McNabb from being a HOF worthy player. "I'm not hesitating on that. The list is comprised of 122 players. His 98 regular season wins are more than by Ken Stabler and Steve Young, and his 234 career passing touchdowns are more than by Joe Namath and Kurt Warner. However, when looking at a player's entire career, how can we leave out how much they meant to a franchise, or even to an entire city? SU currently has eight, which is tied for seventh all-time with Alabama. He may never have won a Super Bowl. And his 234 career touchdowns is #29 with Tony Romo and, again, Dave Krieg ahead of him. McNabb played from 1999 to 2011 and was on the Eagles from 1999 to 2009. Heres another defensive crime committed by the Hall. Lets hope they go in together at some point. McNair won a league MVP award, took two teams to division titles and was outstanding in the community. The Eagles famously selected McNabb second overall instead of star running back Ricky Williams in 1999, much to the chagrin of fans in attendance that night in New York. McNabb was asked what makes a Hall of Famer: "First of all is his numbers. Anderson also was respected off the field after spending 16 seasons in Cincinnati. Center Jeff Bostic has a case, but Jacoby should be a slam-dunk for the Hall with four Pro Bowls and two first-team All Pro honors over 13 seasons. Many of the early 2000s greatest players will see themselves immortalized in the most distinguished halls of sports history. He passed an average of 8.3 yards/throw. The browser you are using is no longer supported on this site. The Bears didn't pick up Mitch Trubisky's fifth-year option, but the team hasn't lost faith. His 37,276 passing yards ranks #25 on the all time list with names like Dave Krieg and Kerry Collins ahead of him. McNabb never had a dubious distinction like that? Donovan McNabb has been nominated for the Pro Football Hall of Fame every year since he became eligible in 2017, and all three times he has not made the Eli Manning has won two Super Bowls. Although McNabb never won the Super Bowl, he played like a champion, and he should not ever be forgotten. McNabb had to find ways to win playoff games without a true receiving threat for most of his career. "But, people don't realize how hard it is to get to the NFC Championship and to get there five times, and then make it to a Super Bowl? The other two are John Elway and Fran Tarkenton, and that's pretty good company. By choosing I Accept, you consent to our use of cookies and other tracking technologies. All betting content is intended for an audience ages 21+. Manning has a pair of rings, yet in the other four years he made the playoffs, he ended up losing without winning a playoff game. Should he be in the Hall because of his rings alone? Each NFL team's biggest Hall of Fame snub, Ranking eachteams potential Hall of Famers, NFL uniform rankings;why Cowboys are No. He was retro-credited with 127 sacks, and he should have made more than two Pro Bowls. Being voted and inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame is a special honor. If he makes it in, McNabb needs to wear this hat. McNabb was excellent. McNair and Hall of Famers Young and Fran Tarkenton are the only three quarterbacks in NFL history to throw for 30,000 or more yards and rush for 3,000 or more yards. But when you look at the full statistical picture painted by Donovan McNabb throughout his 13-year career, he certainly has a case for the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Hes also third in games played (353), fourth in extra points made (820), and third in career field goals (538). Karras needs more recognition for being one of the leagues most disruptive defensive linemen in the 1960s, when he received four Pro Bowl and three first-team All-Pro nods. He also recorded two of the most prolific consecutive seasons in league history with 19 and 22 sacks in 1983 and 84, respectively. McNabb has always been a favorite of mine. There is no doubt McNabb has been a better overall pro than, say, Eli Manning. I am a Hall of Famer," McNabb told TMZ in 2019, saying that his stats were better than Troy Aikman's.
Angel Stadium Covid Rules,
Anthony Russo Fort Lauderdale,
Articles W